Home › Blog › Polity GK › Sources of the Indian Constitution
Sources of the Indian Constitution: How 10 Nations Inspired India — Complete Guide
🌍 Key Takeaways
- Government of India Act 1935 (~60% DNA): Provided institutional continuity (Federal scheme, Office of Governor, Judiciary, PSCs, administrative procedures).
- United Kingdom (UK): Parliamentary form of government, Rule of Law (Art 14), Single Citizenship, Cabinet system, Bicameralism, Prerogative Writs.
- United States (USA): Fundamental Rights (Part III), Judicial Review, Independence of Judiciary, Preamble ("We the People"), Impeachment processes.
- Ireland: Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP, Part IV), Presidential Election Method (electoral college), nomination of 12 Rajya Sabha members.
- Canada: Quasi-Federalism with a strong Centre, Residuary powers vested in Union (Art 248), State Governors appointment, Advisory jurisdiction of Supreme Court (Art 143).
- Australia: Concurrent List (7th Schedule), Interstate Trade & Commerce (Art 301-307), Joint Sitting of Parliament (Art 108).
- France: Republic status, Preamble ideals of Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity.
- USSR (Russia): Fundamental Duties (Art 51A), Socio-Economic-Political Justice in Preamble, Five-Year Planning.
- Weimar Germany: Suspension of Fundamental Rights during National Emergency (Art 359), balanced by the 44th Amendment Act 1978 (Articles 20 & 21 can never be suspended).
- South Africa: Amendment procedure (Article 368), Rajya Sabha members election by proportional representation.
- Japan: "Procedure Established by Law" (Article 21), expanded via Maneka Gandhi Case (1978) to include American "Due Process of Law."
Table of Contents
- The Master Blueprint: Government of India Act, 1935
- 1. United Kingdom: The Parliamentary Engine
- 2. United States of America: Fundamental Rights & Judicial Defense
- 3. Ireland: The Social Conscience (DPSP)
- 4. Canada: Quasi-Federalism with a Strong Centre
- 5. Australia: Cooperative Federalism & Free Trade
- 6. France: The Ideals of a Democratic Republic
- 7. USSR (Now Russia): Civic Duty & Economic Planning
- 8. Weimar Germany: Protecting Stability in Crisis
- 9. South Africa: Constitutional Adaptability
- 10. Japan: Legal Due Process
- Quick Reference Summary Table
- Debunking the Myth: Why It Isn't a "Bag of Borrowings"
- Exam-Oriented Quick Revision Points
- Frequently Asked Questions
The Master Blueprint: Government of India Act, 1935
Before looking overseas, the Constituent Assembly examined its own immediate administrative history. Nearly 60% of the Indian Constitution traces its structural and procedural DNA to the Government of India Act, 1935.
Following Partition, severe administrative upheaval, and the integration of over 500 princely states, building administrative machinery from complete scratch risked state failure. The 1935 Act provided essential institutional continuity.
| GOI Act 1935 Feature | Constitutional Application in India |
|---|---|
| Federal Scheme | Division of powers between Centre and Provinces (7th Schedule baseline) |
| Office of the Governor | Executive head for state administration |
| Judiciary Infrastructure | Structural baseline for Federal Court ➔ Supreme Court of India |
| Public Service Commissions | Blueprint for UPSC and State PSCs (Articles 315–323) |
| Administrative Details | Procedural norms maintaining civil administration continuity |
1. United Kingdom: The Parliamentary Engine
Having experienced British administration for two centuries, Indian leaders chose the familiar Westminster model over a US-style presidential system to ensure executive accountability during a fragile transition.
- Parliamentary Form of Government: Executive accountable to elected legislature.
- Rule of Law (Article 14): Equality before law; no individual above legal mandate.
- Single Citizenship: Unified national citizenship (unlike US dual federal/state citizenship).
- Cabinet System & Prime Minister: Executive power rests with Council of Ministers.
- Bicameralism: Two-house legislature (Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha).
- Prerogative Writs: Judicial protections (Habeas Corpus, Mandamus, Certiorari, Prohibition, Quo-Warranto).
- Speaker's Office & Legislative Procedure: Parliamentary rules and privileges.
2. United States of America: Fundamental Rights & Judicial Defense
The US model provided the legal shield protecting individual civil liberties against state overreach:
- Fundamental Rights (Part III): Inspired by US Bill of Rights.
- Judicial Review: Power of courts to strike down unconstitutional laws.
- Independence of Judiciary: Insulation of judges from political interference.
- Preamble Concept: Opening phrase "We, the People..."
- Impeachment & Removal: Procedures for President and SC/HC judges.
- Post of Vice-President: Ex-officio Chairman of Rajya Sabha.
3. Ireland: The Social Conscience (DPSP)
Realizing civil rights alone could not eradicate deep post-colonial poverty, the Assembly adopted Ireland's framework for economic democracy:
- Directive Principles of State Policy (Part IV): Guidelines for establishing a welfare state.
- Presidential Election Method: Electoral College system using proportional representation by single transferable vote.
- Nomination to Rajya Sabha: 12 nominated members with expertise in art, science, literature, and social service.
4. Canada: Quasi-Federalism with a Strong Centre
To guard against post-Partition territorial fragmentation, India rejected traditional US-style state sovereignty in favor of Canada's centralized federation (described by K.C. Wheare as Quasi-Federal):
- Federation with a Strong Centre: Union Supremacy in critical sectors.
- Residuary Powers Vested in Centre (Article 248): Unlisted legislative topics fall automatically under federal domain.
- Appointment of State Governors: Presidential appointment ensuring Central oversight in provinces.
- Advisory Jurisdiction of Supreme Court (Article 143): President seeking apex court legal opinions.
5. Australia: Cooperative Federalism & Free Trade
- Concurrent List (7th Schedule): Shared legislative space for Centre and States.
- Freedom of Trade, Commerce & Intercourse (Articles 301–307): Unhindered commercial movement across state borders.
- Joint Sitting of Parliament (Article 108): Mechanism resolving legislative deadlocks between Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha.
6. France: The Ideals of a Democratic Republic
- Republic Status: Elected Head of State replacing hereditary monarchies.
- Preamble Ideals: Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity.
7. USSR (Now Russia): Civic Duty & Economic Planning
- Fundamental Duties (Article 51A): Added by 42nd Amendment (1976) encouraging civic responsibility.
- Preamble Objectives: Social, Economic, and Political Justice.
- Five-Year Planning Model: Structure for economic development.
8. Weimar Germany: Protecting Stability in Crisis
- Suspension of Fundamental Rights during Emergency (Article 359).
9. South Africa: Constitutional Adaptability
- Procedure for Constitutional Amendment (Article 368): Simple, special, and special + state ratification modes.
- Election of Rajya Sabha Members: Proportional representation by state assemblies.
10. Japan: Legal Due Process
- Procedure Established by Law (Article 21).
Evolutionary Note: In Maneka Gandhi Case (1978), the Supreme Court expanded Article 21 to incorporate the American principle of "Due Process of Law" (laws must also be fair, just, and reasonable).
Quick Reference Summary Table
| Country / Source | Borrowed Key Provisions | Primary Significance |
|---|---|---|
| GOI Act, 1935 | Federal scheme, Office of Governor, Judiciary, PSCs | Administrative bedrock & continuity |
| United Kingdom | Parliamentary system, Rule of Law, Single citizenship, Writs | Executive accountability & legislative framework |
| United States | Fundamental Rights, Judicial Review, Independent Judiciary | Civil liberties & judicial safeguards |
| Ireland | Directive Principles (DPSP), Presidential election method | Socio-economic welfare framework |
| Canada | Strong Centre federation, Residuary powers, State Governors | National unity & structural stability |
| Australia | Concurrent List, Interstate trade, Joint Parliamentary Sitting | Inter-state cooperation & deadlock resolution |
| France | Republic, Preamble ideals: Liberty, Equality, Fraternity | Democratic baseline & philosophical vision |
| USSR (Russia) | Fundamental Duties (Art 51A), Socio-economic justice | Civic responsibility & equitable growth |
| Weimar Germany | Suspension of Fundamental Rights during National Emergency | Emergency management & national security |
| South Africa | Amendment Procedure (Art 368), Rajya Sabha elections | Constitutional adaptability |
| Japan | Procedure Established by Law (Article 21) | Legal procedural safeguards for liberty |
Debunking the Myth: Why It Isn't a "Bag of Borrowings"
When critics accused the Assembly of unoriginality, Dr. B.R. Ambedkar responded decisively:
"As to the accusation that the Draft Constitution has reproduced a good part of the provisions of the Government of India Act, 1935, I make no apologies. There is nothing to be ashamed of in borrowing. It involves no plagiarism. Nobody holds any patent rights in the fundamental ideas of a Constitution." — Dr. B.R. Ambedkar
GLOBAL IDEAS + INDIAN CONTEXT = LIVING DYNAMIC DOCUMENT
Exam-Oriented Quick Revision Points
- 💡 GOI Act 1935: ~60% administrative DNA baseline of Constitution.
- 🇬🇧 UK: Rule of Law (Art 14), Single Citizenship, Writs, Parliamentary System.
- 🇺🇸 USA: Fundamental Rights (Part III), Judicial Review, Preamble "We the People".
- 🇮🇪 Ireland: Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP, Part IV), Presidential Electoral College.
- 🇨🇦 Canada: Strong Centre, Residuary Powers in Union (Art 248), Governor appointment.
- 🇦🇺 Australia: Concurrent List (7th Schedule), Joint Sitting (Art 108).
- 🇫🇷 France: Republic, Liberty, Equality, Fraternity ideals in Preamble.
- 🇷🇺 USSR: Fundamental Duties (Art 51A), 42nd Amendment (1976).
- 🇩🇪 Germany: Suspension of Fundamental Rights during Emergency (Art 359).
- 🇿🇦 South Africa: Amendment Procedure (Art 368).
- 🇯🇵 Japan: Procedure Established by Law (Art 21) expanded via Maneka Gandhi 1978.
Frequently Asked Questions
What percentage of the Indian Constitution is derived from the Government of India Act, 1935?
Nearly 60% of the Indian Constitution traces its administrative DNA to the Government of India Act, 1935, including the federal scheme, office of Governor, judiciary infrastructure, Public Service Commissions, and administrative procedural details.
What provisions were borrowed from the United Kingdom (UK)?
The British model provided the Parliamentary form of government, Rule of Law (Article 14), Single Citizenship, Cabinet system, Prime Minister's office, Bicameralism (Lok Sabha & Rajya Sabha), Speaker's office, and Prerogative Writs.
What key features were borrowed from the United States (USA)?
From the US, India borrowed Fundamental Rights (Part III), Judicial Review, Independence of the Judiciary, the Preamble concept ('We the People'), Impeachment of President and removal of judges, and the Vice-President post as Upper House Chair.
What is the difference between how India adapted US Fundamental Rights vs the original US Bill of Rights?
While US rights were initially near-absolute, Indian framers inserted explicit 'reasonable restrictions' directly into the text (e.g. Article 19(2)) to balance individual liberty with public order, state security, and social welfare.
What features were borrowed from Ireland?
From Ireland, India borrowed the Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP, Part IV), the Electoral College method for Presidential Elections, and the nomination of 12 members to the Rajya Sabha for expertise in art, literature, science, and social service.
Why did India adopt Canada's centralized federal model over America's model?
Following Partition and internal instability, a traditional US-style federation with strong state sovereignty posed fragmentation risks. India chose Canada's quasi-federal model with a strong Centre, vesting residuary powers in the Union (Article 248).
How did the 44th Amendment Act (1978) safeguard fundamental rights during emergencies borrowed from Weimar Germany?
While Article 359 allows suspension of fundamental rights during national emergency (borrowed from Weimar Germany), the 44th Amendment Act 1978 established that Article 20 (protection against conviction) and Article 21 (right to life and personal liberty) can NEVER be suspended.
What did Dr. B.R. Ambedkar say in response to the 'bag of borrowings' critique?
Dr. Ambedkar stated: 'There is nothing to be ashamed of in borrowing. It involves no plagiarism. Nobody holds any patent rights in the fundamental ideas of a Constitution.' The Assembly synthesized global ideas with Indian socio-economic realities.
Indian Constitution Series
Preamble, articles, rights and amendments — stay inside the constitutional-law cluster.
Lock the Provisions
Lock the provisions from this chapter with previous-year polity questions, then revise from the Indian polity notes.
Solve PYQs → Study Notes →